Wishing you a peaceful and healthy New Year from the Prestogeorge family.

Highlander Kreme Coffee

Prestogeorge Coffee & Tea

$16.99
(7 reviews) Write a Review
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Prestogeorge Coffee Co.'s Highlander Kreme Coffee derives from Columbia's finest coffee bean. Our most popular flavor. A heavenly combination of our signature Irish Cream and velvety Vanilla Butterscotch flavors make this coffee insanely delicious.

7 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Highlander Kreme

    Posted by Laurie Lenigan on Jan 30th 2026

    I've been drinking the unique to Prestogeorge Highlander Kreme Blend for over 25 years now. The original Mr. Pestogeorge would grind it up for us - he never let one bean escape that grinder! He was the sweetest man. I live in Texas now butI get my monthly delivery of Highlander Kreme sent to Texas. We're moving back to Pittsburgh in May and I'll be able to now go back into the store to get coffee and talk to all their wonderful employees. Prestogeorge is a Pittsburgh Gem!

  • 5
    Highlander

    Posted by Carol on Jan 29th 2026

    This was my first experience with Prestogeorge coffee. I was blown away with the full bodied flavor. It inspired me to continue trying other flavors and blends. This is still one of my favorites.

  • 5
    A classic that I always go back to

    Posted by Katherine on Jan 28th 2026

    This is one of the first coffee flavors I bought when I came across the store and it's one of my favorites to this day. No one makes it better than prestogeorge!

  • 5
    Always come too! Love it!

    Posted by Karen Litzinger on Jul 16th 2025

    I must have asked someone in the store what was popular 20 years ago, and totally fell in love with Highlander Creme. I’m always asking about what’s in it, the perfect blend. I’ve tried others here but I’m done experimenting. And of course no flavored coffee in a supermarket compares. It’s worth my trip in.

  • 5
    Best Cold Brew

    Posted by Maple on Apr 18th 2025

    Seriously, this makes the BEST cold brew. It has a lovely, full flavor, that doesn't come off as remotely artificial—that I've never found in any other flavored coffee. Sweet and floral, but not too much of either. Perfect when steeped and strong for cold brew!

  • 5
    One of the Best

    Posted by Debbi Tyson on Oct 19th 2023

    One of my very favorites. The mixture of flavors is just incredible and Highlander coffee is both on my regular coffee flavor rotation and the coffee flavor I choose to gift to others for special occasions.

  • 5
    Favorite

    Posted by Bridget Yeager on Mar 11th 2021

    This was one of the first coffees that my boyfriend and I ever tried from here and we love it! It's one of our favorites! The Irish cream flavor is really nice.