Fresh Roasted Every Half-Hour
Origins, blends, and flavors, all sustainable.
Pittsburgh’s Largest Tea Selection
The world’s finest tea, sourced just for you.
Always by Hand, Always with Heart
Coffee and tea excellence, a family tradition.
Features
Visit Us in Person!
Located in the heart of Pittsburgh’s premier and historic specialty shopping district, our humble store offers everything we do online, plus more! Take-out drinks, great people, and the best smells in Pittsburgh! 1719 Penn Avenue, In the Strip!
Best-Seller Coffee Bundles
New to Prestogeorge? Can't decide? Our best-seller coffee bundles include three pounds of our best-selling coffees in your favorite roast style or flavor preference. They make great gifts too! Gift box option available.
Local Honey from Huckle Bee Farms
20+ flavors of Pennsylvania local honey. Huckle Bee Farms, located in Ligonier and Bedford, PA, infuses their raw honey with natural organic fruits and vegetables to create irresistible flavors that take your tea, coffee and culinary creations to another level. Uninfused options too! Give your tastebuds a treat.
Nicaragua Honey Processed Coffee
It's back with some added flair! 100% Organic and the very first coffee of ours to be roasted between a City Light Roast and a Full-City Medium Roast. Balanced fruity acidity with a smooth caramelized flavor.
#1 Best-Selling Coffee – J.P. Hearty Blend
The answer to the question: “What should I try first?” Our definitive house blend coffee. J.P. Hearty blend was created by our founder, John Prestogeorge (1926-2010), over 40 years ago. You will get a smooth cup with a little bit of extra oomph. Not too strong, not too mild, just a very good cup of coffee. All these years later, it is still our top selling blend, earning it the honor of Pittsburgh’s favorite coffee.
Loose Tea Heaven
Our sprawling collection of loose-leaf tea & herbs, is a true treasure trove for any tea enthusiast. This carefully curated assortment features a diverse range of tea types, each offering unique flavors, aromas, and experiences.
Featured Products
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Most Popular Products
New Products
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Add to Cart
The item has been added
Sustainability is Our Mission
Coffee bean sustainability encompasses various practices and initiatives aimed at minimizing environmental impact, ensuring fair treatment of workers, and promoting long-term viability of coffee production.
Learn More
Testimonials
“Best coffee in Pittsburgh. Simple as that.”
- Andrew D.
“Best ground coffee and loose leaf tea, always fresh, always hospitable. We actually get their coffee delivered but we always stop here when in town.”
- Jenn G.
“Moved out of Pittsburgh 2+ years ago and STILL make it my business to come to Presto whenever I'm back in town. I LOVE THIS PLACE, ONLY PLACE I GET MY TEA AND COFFEE FROM. Staff continues to be knowledgeable and will mix you a custom blend on the spot if needed. Long live Prestogeorge!!”
- Gabe L.
“There are just so many choices! Coffee roasted fresh daily, teas galore, so many accessories to elevate your coffee or tea experience… You can't beat the prices, and sniffs are always free. The staff is always friendly and knowledgeable, always happy to answer questions and chat a bit.”
- Megan K.
“The best place to buy coffee and tea! Fantastic selections. The most warm and welcoming people who are always ready to help and provide suggestions. We won't buy our coffee or tea anywhere else in Pittsburgh (or online)!”
- Matt V.
“Every coffee flavor bean you can dream of (or even think of!) is here for sale! Great staff! Friendly & welcoming! We got a couple bags of their roasted flavored coffees for gifts. It smells like heaven in here for a coffee lover”
- Heather B.
“I've been buying whole bean coffee from Prestogeorge for years, absolutely love this place.”
- Thomas S.